Beyond Comparison: Sex and Discrimination by Timothy Macklem

By Timothy Macklem

Timothy Macklem argues that the guts of discrimination lies now not in destructive comparisons with the remedy and possibilities that males get pleasure from, yet fairly, in a denial of assets and possibilities that girls have to lead winning and significant lives. This paintings can provide to be a milestone within the debate approximately gender equality and should curiosity scholars and pros fascinated with felony conception and gender experiences.

Show description

Read or Download Beyond Comparison: Sex and Discrimination PDF

Similar feminist theory books

The Beauty Myth How Images of Beauty Are Used Against Women

In a rustic the place the typical lady is 5-foot-4 and weighs a hundred and forty kilos, videos, ads, and MTV saturate our lives with unrealistic pictures of good looks. The tall, approximately emaciated mannequins that push the most recent miracle beauty make even the main convinced lady query her visual appeal. Feminist Naomi Wolf argues that women's insecurities are heightened by way of those photographs, then exploited through the nutrition, beauty, and cosmetic surgery industries.

The Women and Language Debate: A Sourcebook

This ebook "gathers jointly for the 1st time influential essays from the fields of psychoanalysis, anthropology, linguistics, and literary feedback and thought that experience sparked the controversy approximately language and gender because the flip of century. "

The Routledge Companion to Social Theory (Routledge Companions)

The Routledge better half to Social thought presents an authoritative, accomplished and provocative advent to the most important traditions of inspiration in social thought at the present time. This ground-breaking reference paintings brings jointly significant individuals, either demonstrated and emergent new voices, to mirror at the ways that social thought sheds gentle at the modern social global.

Elizabeth Wolstenholme Elmy and the Victorian Feminist Movement: The Biography of an Insurgent Woman

This booklet offers the 1st full-length biography of Elizabeth Wolstenholme Elmy (1833–1918) – anyone talked about between contemporaries as "the gray subject within the mind" of the late-Victorian women’s circulation. A pacifist, humanitarian "free-thinker," Wolstenholme Elmy was once a debatable personality and the 1st lady ever to talk from a public platform relating to marital rape.

Additional info for Beyond Comparison: Sex and Discrimination

Example text

This means that roles can release people from some of the destructive consequences of blame. Even the fact that roles are typically assigned to people according to the circumstances of their birth and sex, to the extent that that is true, frees people from the angst produced by the knowledge that they may do anything, coupled with the fear that they may lack the capacity to do anything very well, or that they do not know themselves and the world well enough to choose what genuinely suits them from among what is genuinely worth doing.

This means that we must often decide which option to pursue when there is reason to pursue to be mistaken about what is valuable (as would be the case on any objective account), because the basis of value is not answerable to value judgment itself. Further, any change in the basis of value (from culture to sexual identity, for example), must be predicated not on the wrongfulness of sex discrimination (for relativist values cannot be wrong in themselves) but on the existence of independent grounds to believe that the existing basis of value is mistaken (so that value is properly related to sexual identity rather than culture, for example).

16 the issues as the court did in fact, the content of the community standard of tolerance, for it is entirely possible that the community standard of tolerance is discriminatory, although it happened not to be so in this case (or so we may assume). IV. Comparison and Noncomparison As I have said, all these are difficult questions. And yet the alternatives, if less difficult, are less persuasive, for the reasons sketched in the first two sections. One of the great attractions of an egalitarian approach to sex discrimination, for example, is that it is straightforward and easy to apply.

Download PDF sample

Rated 4.01 of 5 – based on 16 votes